Who is Red John

Let's focus on the question that How can Red John know Jane's happy memory? It can be explained in several ways. Jane's most vulnerable moment lying in hospital Red John got close to him to reach information or Red John is someone very close to him/ know someone very close to him. This option also brings to our mind his father. Last time we saw him when Jane escaped from the circus. Hereby, he lost Jane with a generous income and this left him in a difficult situation. Also we do not know much information about his father. In other words, they do not have good father-son relationship, I mean his father as valuable as gold mine for Red John.

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

Even the name of Bob Kirkland is deleted from the list because of his death, I believed that his twin brother Michael still alive and we can say Kirkland's picture is on the list. In season 5 episode 18, Kirkland killed Red John's fellow and he exactly asked this "Have you seen me before?" so far it sounded meaningless but we learned 6x4 Kirkland has a twin who knows Red John. And he figured out Michael is alive, he is in doubt in Red John uses his brother for his dirty jobs. That is why he asks all Red John suspects "Do you recognize me?". Up to present, we must have seen Michael in some scenes but we did not realize for now. We thought him Bob.

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

I think that Kirkland is Red John because Red John has to be a very powerful figure to do all the things he has done. Also Red John was able to figure out who was on patricks list so since Kirkland had those two agents break into patricks office it makes kirkland a probable suspect. Also Rosalind Harker probably would not have been attracted to an old man like bret stiles. I know that she is blind but I think that she would be able to tell if red john was old. I dont think red john is brett partridge because he is to young and red john has been killing for a long time. Remember in the episode red barn when the team figured out that red john was a member of visualize 25 years ago? Well Kirkland looks like the perfect age for that. Brett Partridge has the voice of red john but he is too young he is second on my list though.

Argue on this theory or rate it.

plausible

unlikely

Theories of Pape sy (3)